The Art of Being Wrong
click rosh hashana 2026 to download
The Art of Being Wrong
Humility isn’t a virtue you add to teshuvah — it’s the thing that makes teshuvah possible. A person sunk deep in arrogance cannot do teshuvah — not because Hashem won’t accept it, but because teshuvah has a first step, and that step is the one sentence his ego cannot afford to say: I was wrong. Everything else in the process is downstream of that sentence. Charatah, viduy, kabbalah al ha’atid — none of them can begin until a person is willing to be wrong out loud. Humility isn’t a nice trait to bring along to Elul. It is the key that opens the door.
A person who wants his sins erased as though they never were must be an anav. He must be humble. Not sorry. Not devastated. Humble. Those are not the same thing. “I was wrong” is different than “I am sorry.” There is a real difference between self-criticism and self-honesty. Self-criticism feels like teshuvah. Self-honesty produces it. On the very first Rosh Hashana, Adam Harishon was given a chance to admit that he sinned, when G-d asked him Ayekah -where are you?… He could have just admitted, and he would have saved the world from the curses he brought upon it… Death, difficulty bringing children and bringing them up, difficulty making livelihood, and mood swings of women… But he blew it. Approaching Rosh Hashana, we have a chance to fix that, and admit, that we were wrong, and have a great year ahead.
This is scientifically backed. Humble people learn more. Intellectual humility — seeking out challenges, persisting after setbacks, going back to repair what you got wrong — is how we actually learn. Humble people see more: people with intellectual humility pay closer attention to the real strength of evidence, and spend measurably more time reading arguments against their own position than people low in it. Humble people are more social, too. Why? Because the proud person isn’t merely less pleasant to sit next to — he’s also receiving less information about reality. He walks through the world with a smaller dataset and more confidence about it.
On Rosh Hashana you have one job. Just one: to crown G-d as King. What does that mean? It means you totally accept and want your world just as He created it — that only He can change it, and that you accept subservience to His will over your own. In Hebrew this is essentially two concepts: Shiflut ha’adam v’gadlut haBorei — the smallness of the person, the greatness of the Creator. In one word: humility. There is only one way to achieve Jewish Humility, the smallness of the person, and that is through focusing on the greatness of the Creator. The time of the year that we are supposed to achieve this, is on Rosh Hashana, when we blow a bent over shofar of a ram, to remind us to be humble.
When someone shows humility, G-d forgives all of his sins. We learn this from Shaul HaMelech. He was embarrassed to ask the Urim V’Tumim, through the Kohen Gadol, whether he would win the war, because he had killed out the city of Kohanim, Nov. So instead, he brought down Shmuel’s soul through witchcraft to ask him directly. Shmuel told him: tomorrow you will be with me in Gan Eden, in my portion — עמי במחיצתי. That is the greatest Olam Haba a person can reach. But what about Shaul’s sin? Not killing Agag, killing the city of Kohanim, the witchcraft? The Talmud tells us it was all forgiven, because Shaul was embarrassed by his own sin: “כל העושה דבר עבירה ומתבייש בה מוחלין לו על כל עונותיו” (Berachos 12b).
This is why in Parashat Nitzavim, when someone refuses to admit he is wrong, the worst things in the world can happen to him — and that itself comes from G-d’s mercy, YKVK, not His judgment, Elokim. “Perhaps there is among you a man, woman, family, or tribe, whose heart strays this day from Hashem (YKVK) our G-d, to go and worship the idols of those nations… And it will be, when he hears the words of this oath, that he will bless himself in his heart, saying, ‘I will have peace, even if I follow my heart’s desires’… Hashem (YKVK) will not be willing to forgive him; rather, Hashem’s (YKVK) fury and His zeal will fume against that man, and the entire curse written in this book will rest upon him, and Hashem (YKVK) will obliterate his name from beneath the heavens.”
Since when is G-d so tough? Doesn’t G-d want to forgive — חנון המרבה לסלוח? Isn’t He הרוצה בתשובה?
G-d is tough on those who carry haughtiness and refuse to reflect and admit they were wrong — and this, too, comes from His mercy. Because the solution to all of life’s problems is humility: dependency on G-d. Every one of life’s problems lives in the space where we believe we are, or could be, independent of Him.
The Chida writes that the entire power of the Satan — the place where he traps you — is by un-humbling you. The numerical value of the word ענוה is 131. The numerical value of ס’ מ’ א’ ל’, the Satan’s name, is also 131. The way to fight the Satan is to learn mussar and find out where you were wrong — because once you become humbled, the Satan can’t touch you.
Knowing all of this is not the same as living it. You can understand every line above and still wake up tomorrow defending yourself in an argument you already lost. Humility is not a mood you arrive at by inspiration. It is a skill — and like every skill, it is built through practice, not through insight.
Most mussar on this subject stops at the diagnosis. You get told, correctly, that pride blocks teshuvah, that Hashem hates a haughty heart, that the anav sees more and learns more. All true. All useless without a method. Nobody became humble by agreeing that humility is good. You get humble the same way you get anything else worth having — through reps, done badly at first, done consistently, done past the point where it feels natural. Here are four of them.
1. Shorten the gap.
Start with the smallest unit: the moment you are told you are wrong. Watch your own reaction the next time it happens. Someone corrects you. A spouse points out you said something hurtful. A friend tells you your plan has a flaw. Notice the half-second before you respond. That half-second is where the whole avodah lives.
The practice is simple to state and hard to do: If it used to take you three days and a cold shoulder to admit you were wrong, get it down to three hours. Then three minutes. That’s the whole workout.
2. Go looking for the correction.
Most people can eventually admit a mistake once it’s pointed out. Far fewer ask, “Where am I getting this wrong?” before anyone brings it up. That’s the difference between doing teshuvah when caught and doing cheshbon hanefesh on your own schedule.
3. Repair fast, before the moment cools.
You snap at someone — your spouse, your kid, a coworker. Right after, there’s a window where a real repair costs almost nothing: a sentence, a look, an honest “that came out wrong.” Wait an hour and the same repair costs an apology. Wait a day and it costs a conversation. Wait a week and it costs trust. The math only moves one direction, because the other person is quietly building a story about who you are while you’re waiting for the “right time” to bring it up. The proud person delays repair because admitting fault immediately feels like losing. The humble person repairs immediately because he isn’t counting the score.
4. Practice dependency in small doses.
This is the one that ties back to Rosh Hashana. Crowning Hashem as King isn’t an abstract statement you accept once a year — it means accepting that your world was built the way it was built, and that only He gets to change it, not you, through sheer will and control. Most people spend the other 353 days practicing the opposite: gripping the wheel, assuming outcomes are a direct function of their own effort and cleverness, treating any loss of control as an emergency. Then on Rosh Hashana they’re asked to flip a switch they haven’t touched all year. That’s like never exercising and expecting to run a marathon because you set an intention that morning.
So, build small dependency reps into ordinary weeks. When something doesn’t go your way — a delay, a rejection, a plan that collapses — practice saying, out loud or in your head, “This is what He wants right now,” and mean it, even for thirty seconds, even if you’re back to frustrated a minute later. You’re doing a rep. Shiflut ha’adam v’gadlut haBorei doesn’t arrive fully formed. It’s built the same way any muscle is built — under small, repeated, slightly uncomfortable load.
None of these four practices are complicated. What makes them hard is that they offer no immediate reward. Defending yourself feels good in the moment. Admitting you’re wrong does not. That’s exactly why it works. Shaul was forgiven everything — Agag, the massacre at Nov, the witchcraft — because of one moment of genuine boshet, of being embarrassed by his own sin (Berachos 12b). Not because he suffered enough. Not because he apologized well. Because for one honest moment, he stopped defending himself.
That’s available to you constantly, not once a year. Every correction you receive, every mistake you almost explained away, every moment you choose smallness over being right, is a rep. By the time Rosh Hashana comes, you’re not trying to become humble in one shot. You’ve been practicing all year — and the day simply asks you to do, at full size, what you’ve already been training in miniature.
